Suggestion CBA balance

Poll: Saracens non-elite?
Yes
No
 GoNe_MaD


Joined:  11 Tháng 12 2007
Posts: 41
Đã được sửa7 Tháng 8 2013 - 4:18 pm bởiGoNe_MaD
I think saracens should get the koreans/turks/spain/persians treatment.

As it is right now, they are by far the most overpowered civ in CBA. The only thing that can stop them is teutons and MAYBE a well played mongol/byz.

I think they should start as non-elite. They would still destroy everything, just not as overpowered as they are currently.

Reasons for/against?
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 Pestilence_


Joined:  14 Tháng 3 2012
Posts: 1388
đã Post7 Tháng 8 2013 - 4:20 pm
If you want balance, play something other than CBA. Perhaps Chess.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 GoNe_MaD


Joined:  11 Tháng 12 2007
Posts: 41
đã Post7 Tháng 8 2013 - 7:01 pm
It isn't too terribly balanced. But saracens are over the top. Byz to an extent too.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 Pestilence_


Joined:  14 Tháng 3 2012
Posts: 1388
đã Post8 Tháng 8 2013 - 7:33 am
Goths unbalanced versus Archers. Japanese unbalanced vs UU in general. Teutons unbalanced vs Archers. Infantry unbalanced vs Byzantines. Etc. People enjoy CBA because it's broken.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 JustTesting1234


Joined:  30 Tháng 4 2012
Posts: 304
đã Post8 Tháng 8 2013 - 8:38 am
Goths unbalanced versus Archers. Japanese unbalanced vs UU in general. Teutons unbalanced vs Archers. Infantry unbalanced vs Byzantines. Etc. People enjoy CBA because it's broken.

rofl so for you balance is making everything equal?

goth rapes archers, get raped by melee = balanced

sara rapes everything but teutons = not balanced
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 GoNe_MaD


Joined:  11 Tháng 12 2007
Posts: 41
đã Post8 Tháng 8 2013 - 10:04 pm
rofl so for you balance is making everything equal?

goth rapes archers, get raped by melee = balanced

sara rapes everything but teutons = not balanced

Exactly. Mamelukes are supposed to be weak vs archers/infantry. But they own all of them except teutons.

Goths do own archers. But they get eaten by infantry/cavalry.

Teutons get owned by archers. But they eat infantry.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 Pestilence_


Joined:  14 Tháng 3 2012
Posts: 1388
Đã được sửa9 Tháng 8 2013 - 11:17 am bởiPestilence_
rofl so for you balance is making everything equal?

goth rapes archers, get raped by melee = balanced

sara rapes everything but teutons = not balanced

You're quite dense. I made a point that everything about CBA is unbalanced. I also said people enjoy CBA because it's broken. That would also imply imbalance.

edit; Yes, balance would be making everything equal i.e. Mirror Civ wars.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 [Eot_]Marvel__


Joined:  17 Tháng 2 2012
Posts: 6631
đã Post9 Tháng 8 2013 - 11:23 am
Don't try to apply logic to CBA players Ben. They don't understand
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 JustTesting1234


Joined:  30 Tháng 4 2012
Posts: 304
Đã được sửa9 Tháng 8 2013 - 2:31 pm bởiJustTesting1234
You're quite dense. I made a point that everything about CBA is unbalanced. I also said people enjoy CBA because it's broken. That would also imply imbalance.

edit; Yes, balance would be making everything equal i.e. Mirror Civ wars.

u obviously have not idea of what balance is. balance = pros and and cons makes it equal. not that everything is exactly equal

the game itself is pretty balanced playing non-scenarios, but in cba there is not economy nor sea batles, nor advanced siege units. and for example vikings that are the kings of sea/economy becomes a joke in cba
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 ['RB']Dan


Joined:  17 Tháng 5 2012
Posts: 7313
đã Post9 Tháng 8 2013 - 1:38 pm
u oblivious have not idea of what balance is. balance = pros and and cons makes it equal. not that everything is exactly equal

the game itself is pretty balanced playing non-scenarios, but in cba there is not economy nor sea batles, nor advanced siege units. and for example vikings that are the kings of sea/economy becomes a joke in cba

random is even unfair in rm but as your this big time pro in balance then i'm sure you knew this already
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 Pestilence_


Joined:  14 Tháng 3 2012
Posts: 1388
đã Post9 Tháng 8 2013 - 2:26 pm
u oblivious have not idea of what balance is. balance = pros and and cons makes it equal. not that everything is exactly equal

the game itself is pretty balanced playing non-scenarios, but in cba there is not economy nor sea batles, nor advanced siege units. and for example vikings that are the kings of sea/economy becomes a joke in cba

Obvious or oblivious? Either way that made no sense.

In your implications, you don't consider Mirror Civilizations to be balanced. You consider Goths beating archers and losing to UU Melee as a better form of balance with your pros and cons theory. I'm going to have to disagree with you entirely. I think the word you're looking for is a tradeoff, or a compromise if you will. I can see how you get both mixed up, but you're far from being correct.
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 JustTesting1234


Joined:  30 Tháng 4 2012
Posts: 304
Đã được sửa9 Tháng 8 2013 - 2:38 pm bởiJustTesting1234
fixed

call it whatever you want, the purpose of this thread is to make mamelukes equally in pros than cons

You must login into Voobly to view image


got it?


Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 [Eot_]Marvel__


Joined:  17 Tháng 2 2012
Posts: 6631
Đã được sửa9 Tháng 8 2013 - 3:01 pm bởi[Eot_]Marvel__
You must login into Voobly to view image
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 [Eot_]Marvel__


Joined:  17 Tháng 2 2012
Posts: 6631
đã Post9 Tháng 8 2013 - 3:01 pm
You must login into Voobly to view image
Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
 JustTesting1234


Joined:  30 Tháng 4 2012
Posts: 304
đã Post9 Tháng 8 2013 - 3:13 pm
You must login into Voobly to view image



Đường dẫn | Trả lời | Trích dẫn
[1]234
Hiển thị 1 - 15 ngoài 56 Bài viết
Nhảy Forum
1 User(s) làđọc chủ đề này 30 phút vừa qua
0Thành viên1 Khách

Dân số hiện tại:
AoKTS updates (24 Người chơi)
TDII (20 Người chơi)
Photos of Voobly Players (16 Người chơi)
TIW 2020 Map votes (14 Người chơi)
This is War 2016 (9 Người chơi)
Chủ đề tích cực nhất tuần qua: