you should re read... i said we could... and I told army the same but we wont... we arent kids who are gonna have a cry because we dont get our way after breaking simple rules the way you guys in XceL are doing.
Enjoy your 1 map clan member who wanted in Eot first
We could =/= we will. Just read through this topic, we've made it clear we won't, we just think its lame.some clans are allowed to bend the rules because they kick up a big fuss.
There's been plenty of rules we don't like that we have had support against, but we just accepted it, because, well those are the rules (Rcb fair mod is one example)
you should re read... i said we could... and I told army the same but we wont... we arent kids who are gonna have a cry because we dont get our way after breaking simple rules the way you guys in XceL are doing.
Enjoy your 1 map clan member who wanted in Eot first
u want me to list who is in eot before wanted to join xcel ?
yes id love for you to do that Krasic... whenever you want to thank us for not counter boycotting so TIW can keep moving in the right direction... let us know too
The rule was badly worded but since it did state that he could be allowed to play IF he did not play for another clan - which he didn't - and as such, he can play for XceL, that I agree with.
However, everyone knew in advance what the deadline was for the roster lock and even then Army was reasonable enough to extend the deadline by a couple of hours.
I do not know who Dopey is or what he plays and I do not mind if he plays but we have to stop trying to get exceptions to rules. I am sure the rules are not perfect but Army is putting in a lot of effort into this and yes he might have done some things differently but he is only human. All of you guys participating should cut him some slack.
ViCiouS does not like all the rules but we did not campaign to change or bend or try to obtain an exception for any. If one rules get bent then we will never see the end of it with other rules. Let us be mature and note the shortcomings so they can be fixed in the future and just move on with the tournament we all waited for.
I am not on Eot_'s side as most of you are aware, I'd like to ask xcel and 7th to drop their threat of boycotting TIW and participate so we can have some quality games.
The rule was badly worded but since it did state that he could be allowed to play IF he did not play for another clan - which he didn't - and as such, he can play for XceL, that I agree with.
However, everyone knew in advance what the deadline was for the roster lock and even then Army was reasonable enough to extend the deadline by a couple of hours.
I do not know who Dopey is or what he plays and I do not mind if he plays but we have to stop trying to get exceptions to rules. I am sure the rules are not perfect but Army is putting in a lot of effort into this and yes he might have done some things differently but he is only human. All of you guys participating should cut him some slack.
ViCiouS does not like all the rules but we did not campaign to change or bend or try to obtain an exception for any. If one rules get bent then we will never see the end of it with other rules. Let us be mature and note the shortcomings so they can be fixed in the future and just move on with the tournament we all waited for.
I am not on Eot_'s side as most of you are aware, I'd like to ask xcel and 7th to drop their threat of boycotting TIW and participate so we can have some quality games.
+1 too much effort been put in already to see it put to waste over something so small.
The final date for all rosters given will be the 31st of January, no exceptions will be made. It is important to note that players can only play for one clan in the tournament. We will be checking so you have been warned so please dont waste your time because you will get caught and you will get kicked from the tournament and it may even result in further punishments. I know for a start you wont be welcome to play in any future tournaments that I host.
Quote:
The roster lock as been lifted so the teams who played in the qualifiers will now have an opportunity to add to their rosters. The deadline for any updates to rosters will be Sunday the 31st of January at 6pm gmt, no exceptions will be made to anyone looking to join a roster after this date. Also and just to remind you cannot add someone who has played for another clan to your roster, players can only play for one clan. I will need one member from every clan to post their rosters in here making it clear who each player is along with a link to their account
@ Eot_: I honestly dont see a problem with FearMyBanana playing for Xcel. The rules clearly state no other word but "play" so I dont see why there is a missunderstanding here. Maybe he was going to play RCB for DMz vs us but you cant prove it unless he admits it. But he doesnt, he says he didnt know he was in DMzs roster so you have no other choice but to believe it. Rules are rules, thats what Eot_ says, so how about you obey the rules instead of trying to bend them yourself by resticting a player who clearly hasnt played any matches in this TiW yet from playing?
@ Xcel and 7th: Saying you wont be playing in TiW only because of a small thing like this is really childish. I cant believe grown ups would behave like that. We were about to leave TiW too cause some of us were not happy with the map votes (CBA) but I said if thats what the majority wants then we have to accept it and not act like a child who doesnt get what it wants. And you shouldnt act like one either.
Neither XceL or 7th are being childish... we just don't want the rules to be changed again because of certain people's bi!tching, Dopey hasn't played for another clan and didn't even know he was on DMz roster so he therefore is allowed to play for XceL, it's as simple as that.
Ok guys you have put me in a difficult position and it most certainly isnt appreciated. If im strict it creates drama and if im lenient it creates drama. Either way cs loses with the pointless childish drama.
The problem was more on the wording of the rules it shouldve read you cant be listed with another clan. I told others no to certain players because they had been listed even though they didnt play.
On this occasion im going to reverse my decision based solely on me not wanting the tournament to fall apart with teams pulling out. So dopey can play
Enjoy your 1 map clan member who wanted in Eot first
We could =/= we will. Just read through this topic, we've made it clear we won't, we just think its lame.some clans are allowed to bend the rules because they kick up a big fuss.
There's been plenty of rules we don't like that we have had support against, but we just accepted it, because, well those are the rules (Rcb fair mod is one example)
Enjoy your 1 map clan member who wanted in Eot first
u want me to list who is in eot before wanted to join xcel ?
However, everyone knew in advance what the deadline was for the roster lock and even then Army was reasonable enough to extend the deadline by a couple of hours.
I do not know who Dopey is or what he plays and I do not mind if he plays but we have to stop trying to get exceptions to rules. I am sure the rules are not perfect but Army is putting in a lot of effort into this and yes he might have done some things differently but he is only human. All of you guys participating should cut him some slack.
ViCiouS does not like all the rules but we did not campaign to change or bend or try to obtain an exception for any. If one rules get bent then we will never see the end of it with other rules. Let us be mature and note the shortcomings so they can be fixed in the future and just move on with the tournament we all waited for.
I am not on Eot_'s side as most of you are aware, I'd like to ask xcel and 7th to drop their threat of boycotting TIW and participate so we can have some quality games.
However, everyone knew in advance what the deadline was for the roster lock and even then Army was reasonable enough to extend the deadline by a couple of hours.
I do not know who Dopey is or what he plays and I do not mind if he plays but we have to stop trying to get exceptions to rules. I am sure the rules are not perfect but Army is putting in a lot of effort into this and yes he might have done some things differently but he is only human. All of you guys participating should cut him some slack.
ViCiouS does not like all the rules but we did not campaign to change or bend or try to obtain an exception for any. If one rules get bent then we will never see the end of it with other rules. Let us be mature and note the shortcomings so they can be fixed in the future and just move on with the tournament we all waited for.
I am not on Eot_'s side as most of you are aware, I'd like to ask xcel and 7th to drop their threat of boycotting TIW and participate so we can have some quality games.
@ Eot_: I honestly dont see a problem with FearMyBanana playing for Xcel. The rules clearly state no other word but "play" so I dont see why there is a missunderstanding here. Maybe he was going to play RCB for DMz vs us but you cant prove it unless he admits it. But he doesnt, he says he didnt know he was in DMzs roster so you have no other choice but to believe it. Rules are rules, thats what Eot_ says, so how about you obey the rules instead of trying to bend them yourself by resticting a player who clearly hasnt played any matches in this TiW yet from playing?
@ Xcel and 7th: Saying you wont be playing in TiW only because of a small thing like this is really childish. I cant believe grown ups would behave like that. We were about to leave TiW too cause some of us were not happy with the map votes (CBA) but I said if thats what the majority wants then we have to accept it and not act like a child who doesnt get what it wants. And you shouldnt act like one either.
The problem was more on the wording of the rules it shouldve read you cant be listed with another clan. I told others no to certain players because they had been listed even though they didnt play.
On this occasion im going to reverse my decision based solely on me not wanting the tournament to fall apart with teams pulling out. So dopey can play